KATHMANDU, Aug 26: The government led by Prime Minister Balendra Shah scrapped nearly 1,600 appointments made by previous governments through an ordinance, arguing that key positions, from universities to important state bodies, had been filled on the basis of political patronage. It promised a new system in which merit and competence, rather than political affiliation, would determine appointments. The pledge won considerable public approval.
But five months into the government’s tenure, the appointment process looks increasingly familiar. Although the government has projected open competition, it has faced accusations of favouring people close to those in power. The faces in government may have changed, but the culture of appointments appears largely unchanged.
Important positions, including ambassadorial posts, have remained vacant for months as the government struggles to move from the principle of “merit first” to actual appointments. Concerns have also emerged over constitutional inclusion and geographic representation. While the 15-member Cabinet includes stronger representation of women, Indigenous nationalities, Madhesis, Dalits, Tharus, Muslims and other marginalised communities than previous governments, the same pattern is not visible in appointments to state bodies.
The government appointed five women, Sobita Gautam, Pratibha Rawal, Geeta Chaudhary, Nisha Mehta and Sita Badi, to the initial 15-member Cabinet. It also included Deepak Sah, Gauri Kumari Yadav and Ramji Yadav from Madhes. But Cabinet representation alone cannot establish that the government is following an inclusive approach across the state.
Open competition, zero women
The government introduced the Integrated Procedure for Selection and Recommendation of Vice Chancellors of Universities, 2083, under which candidates applied openly and were shortlisted and evaluated by expert panels. A total of 218 applications were received for eight universities.
By the end of the Nepali month of Shrawan, the government had appointed vice chancellors at nine universities. Every appointee was a man. The appointments at Lumbini Buddhist University and Nepal Open University followed a different process, but women’s representation in the top university leadership remains zero.
The government maintains that the best candidates were selected through open competition.
New candidates face same old demands in Baitadi
The appointments include Professor Dr Bhola Thapa at Tribhuvan University, Professor Dr Kishan Datt Bhatt at Sudurpaschim University, Professor Dr Rajan Suwal at Midwestern University and Professor Dr Rishiram Kattel at Agriculture and Forestry University.
Professor Dr Shyam Narayan Labh was appointed at Rajarshi Janak University, Professor Dr Devendra Adhikari at Pokhara University, Professor Dr Sujan Babu Marhatta at Purbanchal University, Professor Dr Bibek Baral at Kathmandu University and Professor Dr Bhim Prasad Khatiwada at Nepal Sanskrit University.
The result raises a basic question: if women have a strong presence in Nepal’s education sector, why have none reached the top university leadership positions through this supposedly merit based process?
Professor Dr Sangeeta Rayamajhi says Nepal has many highly qualified women across professions. “Nepali women are not behind anyone when it comes to qualifications. In most fields, I find them highly capable,” she said, although she declined to comment on the government’s appointments.
Purbanchal University Vice Chancellor Professor Dr Sujan Babu Marhatta defended the process, saying the appointments were based on fair competition rather than political bargaining.
“I was also a competitor. Around 40 people applied for the vice chancellor’s position along with me,” he said. According to him, the government selected capable candidates through competition, regardless of whether they were new or had previously held public positions.
But the final outcome does not resolve the inclusion question. Some appointees have previously held public positions under earlier governments, raising another question: how different is the new government’s appointment system from the old one?
The same pattern is visible elsewhere. Dr Ram Prasad Dhital was reappointed chair of the Electricity Regulatory Commission after 32 people applied, including 10 for the chairperson’s position and 22 for member positions.
Other appointments include Gopal Prasad Bhatt as chair of the Securities Board of Nepal, Sushil Chandra Tiwari as chair of the Public Procurement Review Committee, Devaraj Dhungana as executive director of the Security Printing Centre, Hikmat Bahadur Rawal as general manager of Gorkhapatra Corporation and Suraj Shakya at the Kathmandu Valley Development Authority.
Arjun Ghimire was appointed chair of the Nepal Telecommunications Authority, Umesh Shrestha chair of the Press Council Nepal and Professor Dr Khadga Bahadur KC chair of the University Grants Commission. Again, men dominate the major positions.
Merit and inclusion should not be treated as opposing principles. An inclusive state seeks meaningful participation from communities historically excluded from opportunities. Experts argue that competitive selection can still incorporate inclusion. Minimum qualifications can remain equal for all candidates, while the final selection can also consider the constitutional principle of inclusion.
If open competition repeatedly produces candidates from the same social group, the state must also examine whether structural barriers are limiting others from reaching the final stage.
Appointment process faces legal test
Inclusion is not the only challenge facing the government. Compliance with law and selection criteria has also become a concern.
The Supreme Court recently annulled the appointment of Maheshwar Bhakta Shrestha as executive chair of Nepal Airlines Corporation, ruling that the appointment violated legal provisions. The case involved questions over age and selection criteria.
The ruling sends a clear message to the new government: cancelling old appointments and replacing them with new faces is not enough. New appointments must also comply with law, qualification requirements, selection procedures and transparency standards.
The government also needs to focus less on removing officials and more on filling vacant posts so that state institutions can function effectively.
Of the 1,584 positions left vacant after the government cancelled appointments to various commissions, boards, committees and state-owned institutions through an ordinance, only 198 have so far been filled. The continuing absence of officials has already affected the functioning of several state bodies.
The government promised to break with the old appointment culture. Its recent record, however, suggests that changing the names at the top may be easier than changing the system that puts them there.