POLITICS

Lawyers question legality of Karki's removal as IGP

Lawyers have urged the Supreme Court to reinstate Dan Bahadur Karki as IGP, arguing that the government removed him without providing reasons or following due process despite his fixed tenure.
alt=
By REPUBLICA

KATHMANDU, Nov 18: The government's decision to remove Dan Bahadur Karki as Inspector General of Police (IGP) and appoint him as the prime minister's chief security adviser came under legal scrutiny at the Supreme Court on Tuesday, with lawyers representing him arguing that the move violated the law governing the police chief's fixed tenure.



During a hearing on Karki's writ petition challenging the government's decision, lawyers urged a single bench of Supreme Court Justice Shrikanta Paudel to issue an interim order reinstating him as IGP with immediate effect.


They argued that the government had removed Karki without providing reasons, seeking his explanation or establishing any legal grounds for the decision, despite around 18 months remaining in his tenure.


Related story

Petition questions legality of president's oath


Advocate Tikabahadur Kunwar told the court that the government had acted arbitrarily by removing Karki without following due process. "There was no reason given for removing the IGP, nor was he asked for an explanation," Kunwar said. "The government's decision to remove Karki is fundamentally flawed. Reinstate him as IGP immediately."


Senior Advocate Satish Krishna Kharel also questioned the legal basis of the government's decision, arguing that it had failed to establish grounds for removing an IGP before the completion of his tenure. He cited previous Supreme Court precedents involving former police chiefs Nawaraj Silwal and Hitendra Dev Shakya.


Kharel urged the court to issue an interim order and direct the government to submit its written response within 15 days. He argued that reinstating Karki temporarily would not harm the government, while denying him relief was causing continuing harm to the petitioner.


Senior Advocate and former Attorney General Badribahadur Karki argued that the government could not alter the responsibilities of an IGP at its discretion, given the statutory provision for a fixed tenure. "An IGP is not someone the government can replace simply because it does not like his face," he said. "It cannot send him wherever it wants simply because it no longer wants him in the post."


Senior Advocate Dinmani Pokharel questioned the legal provision under which the government had appointed Karki as the prime minister's chief security adviser. Describing the decision as arbitrary, he urged the court to issue an interim order.


Similarly, Senior Advocate Purnaman Shakya argued that removing a serving IGP and assigning him a position equivalent to a political appointment was legally questionable. He said appointing a retired security official as a security adviser was different from transferring a serving police chief to such a role. "The government cannot make arbitrary decisions regarding a position with a four-year tenure," Shakya said. "Removing a serving IGP is equivalent to dismissing him from office."


The lawyers' arguments centred on the IGP's fixed tenure, the government's authority to remove a serving police chief, the legal basis for Karki's reassignment and precedents set by the Supreme Court in similar cases.

Related Stories
SOCIETY

OCE mulling SEE question banks after multiple erro...

OCE mulling SEE question banks after multiple errors in question papers
SOCIETY

NBA asks PM Balen to ease lawyers’ access to Singh...

Balen-1775026295.webp
POLITICS

Ex-home minister Khand’s lawyers continue to put f...

1684065127_balkrishnakhan-1200x560_20230614161036.jpg
SOCIETY

Defendants' Debate: Rayamajhi's lawyers criticize...

BhutaneserefugeeSCAM_20230517134152.jpg
SOCIETY

Clashes outside Supreme Court as agitating lawyers...

Lawprotest_20211112113104.jpg