ad image small
ECONOMY

Pancheshwar remains confined to discussions

Despite decades of promises and repeated political agreements, the Pancheshwar Multipurpose Project remains stuck on paper, with disputes over water sharing, investment, dam height and benefits continuing to hold it back.
alt=
By DIL BAHADUR CHHANTYAL

DHANGADHI, Nov 19: Whenever the prime ministers of Nepal and India visit each other’s countries, the Pancheshwar Multipurpose Project—an important component of the Mahakali Treaty—often comes up for discussion. The project raises hopes that its construction could open the door to prosperity in Sudurpashchim, but those hopes tend to fade as soon as the prime ministerial visits end.



The idea of building the Pancheshwar Project in the villages of Baitadi and transforming local life with electricity began nearly seven decades ago, alongside the flow of the Mahakali River. After Nepal and India signed the Mahakali Treaty framework in 1996, they agreed to prepare a detailed project report (DPR) within six months and complete the project within eight years. Yet nearly three decades after the treaty was signed, construction has not even begun.


The project has once again come into focus with preparations for Prime Minister Balendra Shah’s visit to India, following the Gen-Z movement and the formation of a government with a near two-thirds majority. There has been discussion that the project will be raised during his visit.


Whether the Pancheshwar Project, an integral part of the Mahakali Treaty, will finally move forward will depend on the discussions and agreements reached during the prime ministerial visit.


The ambitious project aims to generate more than 5,000 megawatts of electricity, provide irrigation to millions of hectares of land on both sides of the border and control floods. Prime ministers of the two countries have held repeated discussions and reached agreements in the past to move the project forward. However, the project has never entered the implementation stage due to India’s reluctance and the failure of the two countries to reach agreement on various issues.


A project locals have heard about for seven decades


The name of Pancheshwar Rural Municipality itself was derived from the project. Residents here have been hearing for nearly seven decades that the project would be built. Despite repeated discussions, little progress has been made, leaving locals increasingly skeptical that it will ever become a reality.


Gorkha Bahadur Chand, chairperson of Pancheshwar Rural Municipality, remembers hearing from his grandfather as a child that the village would be lit up with electricity once the Pancheshwar Project was built. India had identified the dam site for the Pancheshwar Project as early as 1956.


“My grandfather used to say that a dam would be built here and the area would be lit up with electricity. My father was a village head. He too used to say that once the Pancheshwar Project was built, not only our villages but the entire Sudurpashchim would be illuminated. But the project remains exactly where it was,” Chand recalled.


He also remembers the political leadership of the time saying, after the Mahakali Treaty framework was signed in 1996, that the sun would rise from the west once the Pancheshwar Project was built.


“Politics was done only in the name of Pancheshwar,” he said.


According to Chand, the project comes into the spotlight whenever Nepali prime ministers visit India, only for the discussion to die down after they return.


“Nothing tangible can be seen after the prime minister returns from India,” he said.


Even the few buildings constructed at the project site have started deteriorating and falling apart. They do not even have electricity. Chand complains that although millions of rupees have been spent keeping the project office in Kathmandu, the authorities have not paid attention to repairing the dilapidated buildings at the project site.


Locals still forced to cross the Mahakali by boat


Residents of Pancheshwar Rural Municipality depend on Indian markets for daily necessities and other needs. Yet there is not even a suspension bridge across the Mahakali River to facilitate travel to India.


“They have not even built a single suspension bridge so far. Locals have already lost hope that the project will be built,” Chand said.


Related story

APF border out post established at Pancheshwar


He said Pradip Gyawali, who was foreign minister at the time, was invited to the project site and requested to build a suspension bridge.


“We told everyone, but even the bridge has not been built,” he said.


In the absence of a bridge, locals are forced to cross the Mahakali by boat. Chand said some locals have even lost their lives in accidents while crossing the river.


Agreement on electricity, dispute over water sharing


On February 12, 1996, Nepal and India signed the Mahakali Treaty on the integrated development of the Mahakali River, covering the Sharada Barrage, Tanakpur Barrage and Pancheshwar Project. Then-Nepali Prime Minister Sher Bahadur Deuba and Indian Prime Minister PV Narasimha Rao signed the treaty. On September 20, 1996, a joint meeting of Nepal’s Parliament endorsed the treaty by a two-thirds majority.


The Mahakali Treaty stated that a DPR would be prepared within six months, construction would begin immediately and the project would be completed within eight years. However, despite repeated agreements during prime ministerial visits to advance the project, implementation has remained elusive.


The two sides have failed to reach agreement on issues including the benefits from irrigation and flood control, investment sharing, water utilization and the height of the dam. As a result, the DPR itself has not been finalized.


Mahakali water remains the key concern


Officials say there is little disagreement between Nepal and India over sharing the electricity generated by the project equally. Experts, however, say the main dispute concerns the use and sharing of Mahakali River water.


Rishiraj Lumsali, chairperson of the Mahakali Rights Protection Concern Committee and a water resources expert, says India needs the Mahakali’s water more than its electricity.


“India is not looking for electricity; it wants the Mahakali’s water,” he says. “This is also the main reason the Pancheshwar Project has not moved forward.”


He argues that the two countries should use the Mahakali River’s water equally and that India should pay Nepal if it uses more than its share. Therefore, he says, water sharing should remain the central issue.


Article 3 of the Mahakali Treaty gives India priority over the water it is already using and states that the remaining water should be shared equally between the two countries. However, Lumsal says there is confusion because the treaty does not clearly specify how much water India is currently using.


According to him, India is using around 15,000 cusecs of water from the Mahakali River.


He says India has built a canal at the Lower Sharada Barrage and is also using water from the Karnali (Ghaghara) River by mixing it with the Mahakali’s water.


In 1920, during the rule of Prime Minister Chandra Shumsher Rana, Nepal and India had reached an agreement allowing Nepal to use 150 cusecs of water during winter and between 400 and 1,000 cusecs during the monsoon.


“Even now, Nepal has been able to use only 150 cusecs of water,” he said.


Residents of Baitadi, Dadeldhura, Darchula and Kanchanpur along the Mahakali River hope that the Pancheshwar Project will bring electricity and irrigation facilities and help eliminate poverty and unemployment.


What has happened so far?


During Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s visit to Nepal in 2014, he and then-Nepali Prime Minister Sushil Koirala reached an understanding to move the Pancheshwar Project forward. In the presence of the two prime ministers, then Energy Secretary Rajendra Kishor Chhetri and Indian Ambassador to Nepal Ranjit Rae signed a memorandum of understanding.


Addressing Nepal’s Parliament at the time, Modi said construction of the project would begin within a year and be completed within five years. A commitment was made to prepare the DPR within three months, begin construction within a year and complete the project within five years. However, that commitment was not implemented.


The Pancheshwar Development Authority was established in 2014, when Sushil Koirala was prime minister. Its first meeting in September 2014 approved its bylaws. Two months later, the authority assigned India’s consulting company WAPCOS Limited the responsibility of preparing a joint DPR by integrating the separate detailed project reports prepared by the two countries.


The company submitted a draft of the integrated DPR in 2016. Since then, meetings of expert groups have been held repeatedly, but the two sides have still failed to reach agreement on the joint DPR.


According to officials at the Ministry of Energy, Water Resources and Irrigation, most of the technical and staff-level work has already been completed. The remaining task is to make diplomatic efforts at the level of the Foreign Ministry and the prime ministers and reach an agreement.


Can the prime minister’s visit break the deadlock?


The Pancheshwar Project will be included in the agenda of Prime Minister Balendra Shah’s upcoming visit to India. Shaligram Bhandari, joint spokesperson at the Ministry of Energy, Water Resources and Irrigation, said the issue of advancing the project would be raised during the visit beginning on November 22. 


According to him, technical and staff-level work related to the DPR is almost complete.


The project could move forward if a diplomatic agreement is reached at the highest political level. However, the two sides have yet to agree on the draft of the joint DPR prepared after separate studies by Nepal and India.


The major differences concern water utilization, the benefits from irrigation and flood control, cost sharing and the height of the dam.


Disputes also over dam height and investment


The Pancheshwar Project envisages constructing a 315-meter-high dam. However, officials at the ministry say India has proposed either increasing the height of the dam or shifting the dam site to a higher location.


The construction of the dam would require the rehabilitation of residents in areas that would be submerged. The proposed project is expected to submerge a larger area on the Indian side than on the Nepali side. Around two-thirds of the submerged area is estimated to fall in India.


The project aims to generate 4,800 MW of electricity from Pancheshwar and 240 MW from the Rupali Gad project, for a combined capacity of 5,040 MW. The initial study, however, had estimated the total generation capacity at 6,480 MW.


The initial estimated investment required for the Pancheshwar High Dam and Rupali Gad Re-regulating Dam projects was Rs 336 billion.


The estimated cost has now increased to around Rs 600 billion. Nepal has proposed that it invest 30 percent and India 70 percent of the project cost. Nepal argues that India should bear the larger share because it would receive greater benefits from irrigation and flood control. India has not yet agreed to the proposal.


According to sources, discussions are also underway on a 35:65 cost-sharing ratio.


Bhandari, joint spokesperson for the Energy Ministry, also said the two sides have yet to reach an investment agreement.


Once completed, the project is expected to generate significant economic benefits beyond electricity production, including irrigation, flood control, fish farming, carbon trading, tourism, medicinal herbs and fruit production.


Nepal has maintained that India should bear a larger share of the project cost because it would receive greater benefits from irrigation and flood control. However, the project has remained stalled because the two sides have failed to agree on the ratio between benefits and costs.


Opposition from Indian citizens is another obstacle


India’s Champawat district lies across the Mahakali River from Pancheshwar. Residents in Uttarakhand have opposed the project because a large dam at Pancheshwar would submerge settlements in the state. Protests against the project have also been held in Dehradun, Pithoragarh and other areas.


People familiar with the issue say pressure has mounted on the Indian government not to move ahead with the project after local residents protested that thousands of people on the Indian side would have to be displaced by the construction of a large dam.


Lumsal, chairperson of the Mahakali Rights Protection Concern Committee and a water resources expert, says opposition to the project in Uttarakhand has made the Indian side reluctant to proceed.


“More land on the Indian side will be submerged by the Pancheshwar Project. There has been opposition in Dehradun, Pithoragarh and Uttarakhand,” he says. “Therefore, the possibility of the Pancheshwar Project being built is low.”


He also believes India has little interest in advancing the project because of its potential environmental impacts.


The Mahakali River has continued to flow for three decades since the signing of the treaty, but the Pancheshwar Project remains confined to paper because Nepal and India have been unable to agree on how to share the benefits that could be derived from the river.


The issue will once again be raised during the prime minister’s visit, but whether it will finally receive a concrete resolution this time or remain confined to discussions, as in the past, remains an unanswered question.

Related Stories
ECONOMY

Nepal, India set to push for progress on long-stal...

Pancheshwar-1794703770.webp
SOCIETY

One killed, six injured in jeep accident in Baitad...

Accident_20220816184519.jpg
ECONOMY

Pancheshwar DPR: India assures yet again, Will thi...

nepal india flag.jpg
ECONOMY

Experts' group meet begins to finalize Pancheshwar...

PancheshwarMulti-PurposeProject_20231007091055.jpg
ECONOMY

Nepal and India agree to extend the deadline of pr...

9thJCWR_20220924144427.jpeg