Prime Minister Balendra Shah’s state visit to India at the invitation of his Indian counterpart, Narendra Modi, offers an opportunity to strengthen Nepal-India relations and establish a more predictable, productive and mutually beneficial partnership. This is his first bilateral visit since assuming power with a near two-thirds majority on the back of Gen-Z protests demanding good governance, accountability, transparency and a corruption-free Nepal, which were followed by widespread destruction of public property, including Parliament and judicial buildings.
The visit should go beyond diplomatic formalities and mere ceremonial expressions of goodwill. It should be measured by tangible outcomes that improve people's lives. For Nepali producers, this means predictable access to Indian markets; for young people, better employment opportunities; for border communities living along the frontier, safe and hassle-free movement; and for seasonal workers travelling back and forth across the border, protection from harassment, exploitation and unnecessary administrative obstacles.
Nepal’s age-old relations with India are precious. They are multi-layered, multidimensional and comprehensive, sharing deep cultural, traditional and religious links. Both countries have extensive commercial and economic ties. Perhaps no two sovereign nations interact as extensively and comprehensively on a daily basis as Nepal and India. People-to-people contacts constitute the most dynamic dimension of Nepal-India relations. Nepali leaders led by B.P. Koirala actively participated in the Quit India Movement of 1942 against the British colonial empire. India has supported Nepal’s democratic transformation. The two countries share so much in common. No relationship with any other country can substitute for Nepal’s relationship with India. India’s generous assistance has gone a long way in advancing Nepal’s socio-economic transformation. India’s swift and substantial humanitarian and technical assistance in the aftermath of the August 26 Rasuwa-Bhotekoshi floods is deeply appreciated.
The joint statement issued following Indian Foreign Secretary Vikram Misri’s November 4-5 visit to Kathmandu provides an initial framework for the prime ministerial engagements and discussions across a broad agenda. Rather than pursuing an excessively broad and ambitious agenda, both governments should identify a manageable set of priorities, designate responsible institutions, establish implementation schedules and agree on periodic reviews. Such an approach would help translate commitments into measurable achievements.
Trade and economic cooperation should receive immediate priority. Nepal’s widening trade deficit with India reflects not only structural weaknesses in domestic production but also difficulties faced by Nepali exporters in accessing Indian markets. Addressing this imbalance requires a two-pronged strategy: improving market access through bilateral negotiations while strengthening Nepal’s domestic productive capacity. Reliable electricity, efficient transit and transport facilities, predictable taxation and stronger technical skills are essential for enhancing the competitiveness of Nepali enterprises.
Nepal should seek practical improvements with India in customs procedures, testing, certification and transparency. Mutual recognition of accredited laboratories, advance notification of regulatory changes and clear explanations for rejected consignments would reduce uncertainty without compromising legitimate safety and quality standards. Integrated Check Posts (ICPs) along the border should be adequately equipped to carry out these functions. Success should be measured by the delivery of more reliable services.
Trump arrives in Japan for ceremonial visit as trade tensions l...
Connectivity should constitute another major pillar of the visit. Nepal has consistently sought additional air entry routes for its newly built airports and the expansion of regional and international networks. This is in line with the HIT (Highways, Information Highways and Transways) concept for Nepal promised by Prime Minister Modi during his visit to Nepal in August 2014. HIT was subsequently expanded into “Super HIT” in May 2023. The cross-border pipeline in operation between Nepal and India is the first of its kind in the region. The proposed Janakpurdham-Ayodhya railway connection is seen as part of this broader connectivity agenda. Nepal has put in place dependable ground services, efficient passenger processing, convenient surface transport and other necessary promotional measures.
The 2022 Nepal-India Joint Vision Statement on the Power Sector has reinforced energy cooperation, opening up substantial opportunities for mutually beneficial development. Nepal earns export revenue while India gains access to additional electricity. The existing long-term power trade framework provides a basis for further work, but individual projects still require viable financing, transmission connections and dependable long-term electricity sales arrangements. The funding and implementation of proposed infrastructure projects have been plagued by persistent challenges.
Water cooperation requires close attention. Progress on the Mahakali-Pancheshwar Treaty is disappointingly slow. An early breakthrough would strengthen cooperation in water sharing and in assessing electricity, irrigation and flood-management benefits. Every monsoon, Nepal faces inundation due to the unilateral construction of dams and embankments on the Indian side of the border. The visit should focus on implementing existing agreements and removing obstacles that delay approved projects. Across hydropower projects, transparent financing, fair treatment of affected communities and environmental safeguards would improve public confidence. Shared flood early-warning systems, hydrological information and resilient infrastructure offer immediate areas of cooperation that can protect lives on both sides of the border.
Given the longstanding relationship, the future of Nepali recruitment into the Indian military should be approached carefully. India’s November 2026 revision of the Agniveer recruitment framework is cited as an additional route towards regular service, but it does not appear to be sufficient. It requires further clarification regarding recruitment, retention, pay, pension eligibility, disability protection, family benefits and access to remedies for Nepal to make an informed decision. Nepal must also continue to generate employment opportunities at home so that young people have a wider range of meaningful options.
Boundary questions call for calm, sustained engagement. Nepal can clearly articulate its position on Kalapani, Lipulekh, Limpiyadhura and Susta, supported by authenticated historical records and technical evidence, while seeking a mutually acceptable resolution with India. A dedicated political dialogue would allow these concerns to be addressed. Nothing is beyond the statesmanship of the leaders of the two countries. Routine surveying, pillar maintenance and local border administration officials should be authorized to meet regularly through the mechanisms mandated for these tasks.
As agreed by the two governments to review the entire gamut of bilateral relations, the Eminent Persons Group (EPG), comprising four representatives from each country, was formed in 2016. The formation of the EPG was in line with Prime Minister Modi’s commitment, expressed during his visit to Nepal on August 4-5, 2014, to take up all bilateral issues for discussion, including the review, revision and updating of the 1950 Treaty of Peace and Friendship and other existing bilateral agreements between Nepal and India. The group submitted its joint report in 2018. India’s refusal to acknowledge the EPG report has eroded the reservoir of trust.
The visit’s lasting impact will depend on follow-through mechanisms. Such mechanisms could identify gaps between commitments and delivery, recommend necessary corrective measures for priority projects, designate officials to address obstacles and publish a joint progress review every six months. The most useful and important outcome should be laying the foundation for enduring trust and confidence between the two countries. Trust is the key ingredient of any lasting relationship. The restoration of trust at the highest political level will help ensure the timely delivery of commitments and the flow of diplomatic goodwill across all levels of engagement. The fruits of enduring trust must reach ordinary people.
The visit is taking place at a time when the world is undergoing a profound structural transformation. The geopolitical landscape is increasingly characterized by rivalry among the great powers. The global economy is dominated by the United States and China, the world’s two largest economies, while India remains the fastest-growing major economy. Nepal’s future cannot be divorced from its geographical realities. The age-old saying, “where you stand depends on where you sit,” is equally relevant to Nepal’s geographical position. Nepal’s geographical location is the most stable and important determinant of its foreign policy and therefore reinforces the need to remain non-aligned. There is no room for binary choices. Foreign policy is neither an exercise in populism nor in political opportunism. Objectivity and pragmatism demand diplomacy of the highest quality.
Stating that the Himalayas are not peripheral to the planet but an integral part of its life-support system, PM Shah, in his address to the 81st Session of the United Nations General Assembly (UNGA) on September 24, proposed “a Himalayan Climate Resilience Mechanism, led by Nepal, India and China” to facilitate the sharing of satellite data, glacial-lake monitoring and early-warning systems in the wake of the Bhotekoshi-Trisuli disaster. Nearly two months have passed since the address, yet not a single step has reportedly been taken towards operationalising the proposed mechanism. It would be interesting to see how this initiative features during the visit.
The prime minister should frame the visit with a united national voice and thorough preparation, ensuring that all engagements are well planned and properly recorded for future reference. Inter-ministerial and intra-ministerial coordination, as well as consultations across political parties, are essential before embarking on the visit. There must be absolute clarity regarding the call to “carry no baggage from the past and reset Nepal-India relations”, as well as the concepts of Nepal as a “buffer state” and a “vibrant bridge” as articulated by the ruling Rastriya Swatantra Party (RSP).
Foreign policy requires greater clarity, coherence and national consensus in this increasingly interconnected, complex and fast-moving world. The future of Nepal-India relations must rest on mutual trust, mutual sensitivity and mutual respect for each other’s sovereignty, territorial integrity and legitimate security concerns. The warmth of people-to-people contacts should be reflected in state-to-state relations.
(The author is a former Foreign Affairs Adviser to the Prime Minister and currently Vice President of the Nepal Council of World Affairs.)